Fine Gardening Project Guides

Gardening Basics

Guide Home

Top 20 Gardening Tools

Our experts share their favorites—ones that no shed should be without

Fine Gardening – Issue 179
top gardening tools

I can’t remember how many trowels I’ve owned/broken over the years. I have an unmatched ability to shorten the life of any gardening implement used for digging. In my defense, one of those many trowels met its fate by being run over by a car (it’s a long story, don’t ask). But several others broke from bad construction or a flawed design. And it seems that I am not alone in always buying the wrong tools. At Fine Gardening, we get many letters asking for advice on the best pruners or a handsaw that won’t need sharpening after every use.

Learn more: How to Care for Garden Tools

In order to enlighten our readers—and ourselves—we reached out to a gaggle of experts, from landscapers to designers to gardeners who have 50 years of experience, to find out what is in their tool sheds. The following is an array of implements that these gardening rock stars cannot live without—so maybe you shouldn’t either. Meet the experts we interviewed for this piece


Hand trucks are a must-have for heavy moving

Harper Super Steel 700-lb. Platform Hand Truck

Although long a staple of moving companies and grocery-store restockers, the hand truck might be the new best friend of gardeners. When it comes to hauling bags of soil or compost, large pots, or even a rogue paving stone or two, a hand truck can save your sanity and your back. They come in a range of sizes and prices (pictured is the Harper Super Steel 700-lb. Platform Hand Truck), but regardless of the brand, a good one needs a steel frame for strength and inflatable tires for easy rolling across the lawn or up and down steps.

An old, stiff piece of carpet or thick cardboard placed between the hand-truck frame and any pots you might move will help provide a cushion. A bungee cord will also help secure objects while transporting them.­ —Jason Reeves


This digger is great for almost anything

Short-Handled Ho-Mi Digger

The Short-Handled Ho-Mi Digger was first developed in the Bronze Age in what is now Korea. It is hand-forged from steel, making it super strong but extremely lightweight. The unique shape allows you to do a multitude of gardening tasks, from weeding to digging rows for planting seeds. Watch out when handling, though, because that blade is razor sharp.

This is a tool that digs, plants, weeds, cuts, makes a row, backfills, and looks like a deadly ninja weapon. —Susan Calhoun


For smaller jobs, try the mini shovel

Corona Multi-Purpose Mini Shovel

When you first see this tiny tool, you might have to stifle a snicker. But once you get over the shock of the Corona Multi-Purpose Mini Shovel, you’ll start imagining all the things it would be good for—planting in small spaces, to name one. It looks like the offspring of a full-size shovel and a trowel. The wooden handle, made of ash, and the tempered steel blade make it stronger than it appears as well.

The “girl shovel” is what my contractors call it. So many of them ask to borrow it when installing irrigation or in tight spots. I buy one, paint it pink, and then tell them I’ll give them one if they’ll use the pink version. They laugh and laugh, but every time I see them on jobs, these huge guys still have their little pink girl shovel. —Stacie Crooks


Need a weeder that won’t quit? Try a Spring Tine Cultivator

DeWit Spring Tine Cultivator

At first glance, this delicate hand tool looks a lot like a back scratcher. Its real purpose is far more ruthless, however. The thin wires of the DeWit Spring Tine Cultivator glide through soil, gently but effectively pulling out weeds as they go. It’s extremely lightweight yet well made from steel and wood. This type of tool is sometimes called a “scratch cultivator” by the Dutch, who are responsible for its design. If ever there was a tool to pass down to your grandkids as an heirloom piece, this would be it.

This is my all-time favorite tool. It’s sometimes hard to find but invaluable for weeding. The wires pull through the dirt and dislodge roots but don’t disturb the soil—hands-down cool. —Stacie Crooks


You’ll never regret buying this trowel

Corona eGrip Trowel

The only tool gardeners replace more often than gloves is the invaluable trowel. These tools bend, they break, the spade end separates from the wooden handle—it’s the rare trowel that makes it past a few seasons. The Corona eGrip Trowel may just be the last tool of its kind that you have to buy. The cast aluminum spade is molded to the handle as one piece, so no bending or breaking will occur. The handle itself is covered in cushioned rubber for better gripping and comfort, and its slight arch is designed to be better for your joints—truly a blessing during fall bulb planting.

The ergonomic handle is so soft, and it never bends, even when you seriously crank on it. It also has measurements engraved on it for planting bulbs. —Stacie Crooks


King of Spades All Steel Nursery Spade

An indestructible shovel

Whether you’re planting a shrub or prying out a boulder, the King of Spades All Steel Nursery Spade is the only tool you’ll need, according to several of our experts. This line of shovels comes in an array of blade and handle sizes as well as styles (pictured is one with a 13-inch blade and 54-inch handle), but all are made of aircraft-quality tubing with heavy steel blades. Be sure to add on a handy-dandy rubber foot-pad attachment for easier digging.

I can’t remember how many times I have broken wooden-handled shovels. This baby refuses to break, and I use it all the time. Its long blade cuts deeper into the soil than other spades, yielding a larger root ball, which results in less transplant shock. —Andy Brand


A soil knife is an unconventional yet invaluable tool

A. M. Leonard Deluxe Stainless Steel Soil Knife

If you have ever committed the sin of using pruners to quickly dig out a weed or cut through the roots of a plant, please invest in the A. M. Leonard Deluxe Stainless Steel Soil Knife. Use it to plant small transplants and bulbs, slice through dense roots, and even cut twine. The wide rubberized handle makes the knife easy to grip. Buying this tool might add years to your pruners too.

I always keep this tool right next to my pruners on my belt—it is indispensable for weeding with its serrated edge. I also use this knife to plant small perennials, and it comes in handy when teasing roots apart prior to planting container-grown material. —Andy Brand


Avoid electrocution and fumes with a battery-powered hedge trimmer

The Black & Decker 40-Volt Cordless Hedge Trimmer

Even if you don’t have a formal boxwood hedge, you need a trimmer. Fall cleanup goes twice as fast when you can use a power trimmer to cut back clumping perennials, as opposed to using pruners to painstakingly cut a handful at a time. The Black & Decker 40-Volt Cordless Hedge Trimmer is a great choice because you won’t have to drag around a long extension cord or worry about filling/maintaining a gas engine. Be warned: The battery is sold separately with this model, but a charge lasts surprisingly long—6,000 square feet trimmed per charge.

You wouldn’t want to use this for pruning your 500-foot privacy hedge, but it’s great for smaller jobs. It will make quick work of cutting back clumps of ornamental grasses or Siberian iris or of sculpting topiary, if that’s your thing. —Jason Reeves


These pruners are perfect for lefties

Felco 9s

This brand of pruners has long been the industry standard—and for good reason. The blades are made of high-quality steel, while the rubber-coated aluminum handles are lightweight and easy to grip. Several experts have sung the praises of Felcos, but for left-handers, Felco 9s are an invaluable purchase. For righties, try the comparable F-8.

Many knockoffs are out there, but there is no substitute for Felco’s quality—specifically, the F-9, since I am left-handed. I have had mine for 30 years, and they’re still going strong. —Bill Cullina


These pruners are so sharp, you could filet a fish with them

Okatsune 103

It might sound like an exaggeration, but it’s not: Okatsune Bypass Pruners are made the same way as samurai swords are—by forge-laminating hardened steel in a sandwich of softer steel. The result is a pruner that anyone would be happy to go into horticultural battle with. The steel blade is razor sharp and, although not replaceable, is easy to sharpen. The spring-loaded locking/unlocking feature allows you to open and close these with one hand, which our nursery experts appreciated. Okatsune 103 (pictured) is the standard model, but the company does make a smaller pruner for smaller hands.

The blade stays very sharp, is easy to clean and sharpen, and is extremely durable. I have a pair I’ve used almost every day for 27 years. —Ed Gregan


Branches tremble when they see this handsaw coming

The Silky Gomtaro 240 Root-Cutting handsaw

Employees at botanic gardens often have this amazing tool hanging from their belts (in a sheath, of course). The Silky Gomtaro 240 Root-Cutting handsaw has what the company describes as a “precision-ground, razor-sharp blade with 4 cutting angles that provide a fast, clean, and extremely smooth cutting action.” We’d probably just say it’s really freaking sharp. The cushioned rubber handle ensures that you won’t accidentally let this deadly tool slip out of your grip. The 9½-inch blade is large enough to cut through fairly thick branches too.

The blade doesn’t break like most stuff on the market, and it cuts roots as well as branches. When botanizing overseas, I don’t leave home without it. Tony Avent


Orchard loppers tackle those tricky in-between branches

Corona’s High-Performance Orchard Loppers

If you have some pruning that is too big for hand pruners but not worth the effort of breaking out the chainsaw, orchard loppers are your savior. Corona’s High-Performance Orchard Loppers are made of lightweight aluminum, so your shoulders won’t ache after a day of garden chores. The steel bypass blades are super sharp, leading to clean cuts (and they are easy to sharpen!). This model can take down a branch up to 2¼ inches in diameter despite weighing only a little more than 2 pounds.

They are extremely lightweight and cut like a hot knife through butter! I’m addicted to pruning and could not live without orchard loppers. —Barbara Weirich


Long-reach, telescoping pruners get into difficult spots

ARS Long-Reach Telescoping Pruner

The conventional wisdom is that any pruning that requires a ladder should be done by a professional arborist. Thanks to the ARS Long-Reach Telescoping Pruner, you’ll be making far fewer calls to that arborist. The arm length can be extended from 4 to 7 feet or from 6 to 10 feet (depending on the model), and the large blades are capable of cutting branches up to ¼ inch. Specific models have a cut-and-hold feature (pictured), enabling you to guide where the pruned material drops. This could come in handy if you’re trying not to squash the garden below with errant pruning debris.

When your garden has deep borders, you simply cannot exist without long-reach pruners. —Barbara Weirich


An upside-down sprayer gets under leaves without a hassle

Chapin Upside Down Trigger Sprayer,

Pests such as aphids and spider mites like to hide on the undersides of leaves, and there’s nothing more frustrating than trying to apply a dose of organic insecticide in those tricky spots. Ordinary spray bottles (like those that come prefilled with liquid pest remedies) don’t work when tipped upside down. Enter the Chapin Upside Down Trigger Sprayer, designed to work when you need to spray underneath the leaves of a plant. Each bottle holds 32 fluid ounces.

It’s ideal for chores that require spraying the undersides of leaves, such as when applying Cloud Cover to protect Japanese maple leaves from burning in low-humidity climates. —Susan Morrison

A glove that fits snugly and lasts a long time

If you’re like a lot of gardeners and go through gloves like toilet paper, you might want to try Showa Atlas 370 Nitrile Gloves (photo above). They’re lightweight and very stretchy, allowing you to bend your fingers around weeds without feeling inhibited. However, a pliable rubber/nitrile coating on the palms gives them the toughness of heavier-duty gloves. Bonus: They hold up well against multiple trips through the washing machine.

These gloves provide a much higher level of dexterity than cloth or heavier rubber gloves do. I’ve also found them in a 3-pack—perfect for people like me who manage to lose several pairs every year. —Susan Morrison


The Hasegawa Tripod Ladder
Photo: courtesy of Susanne Ormond

With this sturdy ladder, you won’t break your neck

Although possibly not the first tool that jumps to mind when it comes to gardening, a proper ladder can literally mean the difference between life and death. And though there are many aerial tasks better left to professionals, sometimes you just need a ladder (think trimming hedges, picking fruit, or occasional pruning). The Hasegawa Tripod Ladder (available in several sizes) is super stable—even on uneven ground. It has a wide base, deep steps, and an adjustable back leg for rough terrain. The biggest surprise with this well-built piece? How incredibly light it is. The 7-foot model (pictured) weighs less than 20 pounds.

The stability of this ladder is greatly reassuring; plus, the tripod design allows me to get in close to where I need to be. My old ladders now sit idle while my Hasegawa and I roam the garden looking for projects. —Gary Lewis

Potato forks double as rakes and cultivators

The Union Razor-Back Potato Refuse Hook

You don’t need to be a farmer in Idaho to use or covet a potato fork. It’s a useful tool when it comes to scratching compost into the first few inches of soil or raking through a bed to collect leaves and stones. Normally, potato forks have three or four tines that are set 1 to 2 inches apart. The Union Razor-Back Potato Refuse Hook has four wide-set tines made of durable steel, so they don’t bend easily. The extra-long wooden handle (4½ feet long) allows you to reach quite a distance into a bed without much trouble.

Lighter than the typical garden rake, it’s easier to work a potato fork quickly around objects and quickly flick stones and debris to the side. It’s a pretty good back scratcher too. —Ed Gregan

The weird but practical award goes to . . . the nut picker-upper

Holt’s Nut Wizard

This unique tool looks like it should come with a hamster that runs around the metal cage at the end. The admittedly strange appearance of the Holt’s Nut Wizard, however, does not detract from its amazing nut-gathering abilities. If you have nut-producing trees like oak or black walnut, you know that picking up all those nuts can be an exhausting and back-breaking chore. But if you leave them on the ground, they’ll sprout thousands of seedlings next year. And if you attempt to mow the lawn, you risk shooting acorns around like deadly projectiles. Simply roll the caged end around, and the flexible wires part for easy collection. Different sizes are available based on the nut size (pictured is the 12-inch Nut Wizard).

My neighbor has a huge shagbark hickory that hangs over my lawn, and for about 10 weeks it drops nuts. This rolling nut vacuum actually makes cleaning up fun (sort of). What a back saver! —Tony Fulmer

If you’ve got clay soil, you need a spork

DeWit Spork

Is it a pitchfork or a shovel? Technically it’s neither, but the DeWit Spork combines the best qualities of both. The carbon steel tines cut smoothly into even the most compacted of soils, but with reduced friction, thanks to the open cut-outs in the blade. The wood handle is made from ash, so it’s extra sturdy and holds up well when prying out larger perennials and shrubs for transplanting. Also, the Spork is great for edging beds, cutting a deeper and cleaner line than any so-called professional edger out there.

I love the way the toothed tines cut through the heaviest clay soil, but the open areas in the “body” reduce the compaction that I would get with a solid-bladed spade. —Tony Fulmer


Garden Plus Steel-Handle Steel-Head

A full-size rake in a pint-size package

Is there anything worse than storing leaf rakes? They take up a ton of space and always seem to fall off their hooks or holders. But they are a necessity come fall clean-up time. The answer to these problems is an expandable rake, and the Garden Plus Steel-Handle Steel-Head is one of the best. You can lock the fan into a compact, 6-inch version (pictured), or pull back and allow the steel head to expand to 15 inches. In its condensed form, the rake is perfect for sneaking in and around plants to get at leaves, and when flushed out, it acts like a normal fan rake. The handle telescopes, stretching to 35 inches at full length.

Not all debris can be blown out from hard-to-reach spaces, especially if you’ve just washed your windows or glass doors. I really like the adjustability and versatility of the expandable rake. —Tony Fulmer

Tool Maintenance 101

It isn’t enough just to have the best tools; you then need to take care of them so that they stay in tip-top condition. The following are a few tips from nurseryman Ed Gregan on how to properly service your shovels and pruners.

Tip 1: After using steel garden tools, clean any soil or debris from them with a wire brush, and then wipe them down with an oil rag. Encrusted soil and rust make tools heavier and less effective.

Tip 2: Every few years, apply paste wax (available at hardware stores) to tools with wooden handles to help recondition the wood.

Tip 3: Always keep your pruners clean (free from sap), lubricated with pruner grease (available at garden centers and online), and stored in a leather sheath to protect the blade and keep it sharp.

Meet our experts


Ed Gregan Susan Morrison Jason Reeves
Ed Gregan: Nurseryman with 30 years’ experience and a field representative for Carlton Plants, a wholesale bare-root grower in Dayton, Oregon. Susan Morrison: Landscape designer from San Francisco and longtime member of the Association of Professional Landscape Designers. Jason Reeves: Curator of the University of Tennessee Gardens in Jackson and international garden tour leader.
Stacie Crooks Bill Cullina Andy Brand
Stacie Crooks: Garden designer in Seattle with more than 20 years’ experience. Bill Cullina: President/CEO and former director of horticulture for the Coastal Maine Botanical Gardens in Boothbay. Andy Brand: Nursery manager of Broken Arrow Nursery in Hamden, Connecticut, and past president of the Connecticut Nursery and Landscape Association.
Susan Calhoun Tony Fulmer Tony Avent
Susan Calhoun: Owner of Plantswoman Design, a landscape design and build firm on Bainbridge Island, Washington. Tony Fulmer: Chief horticulture officer at Chalet, a specialty nursery in Wilmette, Illinois, with four decades of gardening experience. Tony Avent: Renowned plantsman and proprietor of Plant Delights Nursery and Juniper Level Botanical Garden in Raleigh, North Carolina.
Gary Lewis Barbara Weirich
Gary Lewis: Owner of Phoenix Perennials in Richmond, British Columbia, and director on the board of the international Perennial Plant Association. Barbara Weirich: Owner of a private, 5-acre botanical garden in Benton Harbor, Michigan.


Danielle Sherry is the senior editor who wishes she had put half of these tools on her wish-list to Santa.

Photos by Danielle Sherry except where noted

Previous: A Fresh Approach to Foundation Plantings Next: Tools for Working the Soil
View Comments


  1. user-7399406 06/17/2022

    Item numbers would have been helpful for ordering after getting such sage advice

Log in or create an account to post a comment.

Gardening Basics

Gardening Basics

Expert advice for the beginner

View Project Guide

View All Project Guides »

Become a member and get unlimited site access, including the Gardening Basics Project Guide.

Start Free Trial

Planning Your Garden
Seed Starting
Maintenance and Troubleshooting
Easy-to-Grow Plants