Fine Gardening Project Guides

Fruits and Vegetables

Guide Home

Top 5 Tomato Questions Answered

A leading expert answers readers’ questions about growing these veggie-garden staples

We shared with Scott Daigre—the owner of Powerplant Garden Design, based in Ojai, California—a few of our readers’ most pressing tomato questions. As the host of Tomatomania!, the world’s largest tomato seedling sale, and co-author of the book Tomatomania: A Fresh Approach to Celebrating Tomatoes in the Garden and in the Kitchen, Scott is an expert in all things tomato. Here are his answers.

Tomato Question 1

I live in the Pacific Northwest and always have a hard time getting tomatoes to ripen in our cool climate. I’m sick of just growing cherry tomatoes. Do you have any suggestions for a beefier short-season option? —Alice Brown, Bremerton, Washington

SD: Tomatoes that are on the small side and that ripen early in the season (like the cherries you mention) are generally the most dependable in your area. While the weather patterns in a given year will have loads to do with your success rate, any short-season tomato—a variety that needs 70 days or less to mature—should work for you.

A beefy option is a tough part. You’ll rarely have any luck with the biggest beefsteaks, but there are some medium-size varieties that are candidates in your area. Keep an eye out for early hybrids, like ‘Sweet Tangerine’, ‘Oregon Spring’, and ‘Jet Star’. While neither beefsteaks nor cherries, choices like ‘Carmello’, ‘Stupice’, ‘Jaune Flamme’ (pictured), ‘Earliana’, ‘Fourth of July’, ‘Champion’, and the classic ‘Early Girl’ could work as well. An heirloom group commonly referred to as the “Siberians” might also offer you some options. ‘Gregori’s Altai’ (pictured) is one of my favorite medium-size varieties in this group.

No matter what variety you decide to grow, remember that where and how you grow these choices will be important. Here are some tips for success in cool situations:

  • Find all the sun you can. Ten hours is optimal, which is more than the normal “full sun” requirement.
  • Grow in pots. The soil warms faster in pots; therefore, the plant is warmer overall.
  • Prune, at least a little bit. This helps get all available sun into the center of the plant, warming it up.
  • Screen your garden from breezy conditions. Plant behind the house or a hedge, or build a temporary screen around your tomato patch. A stucco or light-colored wall that blocks breezes can also offer valuable reflected heat and light, so use that to your advantage.

Tomato Question 2

I need to grow tomatoes in containers because of limited space. I’d like to use some beautiful glazed terra-cotta ones, but I’m afraid that they aren’t the best choice for the plants. What do you think? —Dave Exeter, New York

SD: First, growing tomatoes in containers (large ones) is a great idea. Second, yes, the kind of pot you use can make a difference in the success or failure of your season. The one you describe might not be optimal—unless you take some precautions.

Although tomato plants thrive in full (hot) sun, the roots want a different situation: deep, cool soil. Trying to accomplish those conditions in pots can be difficult. I’d suggest you use containers that are at least 15 inches in diameter and 15 inches deep (bigger is better) and made out of a material that won’t heat up unbearably during the summer, thereby subjecting the roots to ridiculously hot temperatures. Wooden containers, pulp pots (shown above left), and collapsible felt pots are all good candidates.

Clay pots can heat up quickly. If, however, it makes no sense for you to buy a whole new fleet of pots (or if that glazed pot matches perfectly with your house color), go ahead and plant it up.

Step 1: Be sure to provide rich soil for your container. Start with a premium potting soil and then amend with compost or worm castings, just as you would for plants in the ground.

Step 2: See what you can do to limit the amount of direct or reflected sun on the pot surface. Mulch the surface area at the top of the container, and push other containers around the tomato planter to protect the sides of the pot from too much sun. This reduces the soil temperature inside the pot, which threatens the roots and, hence, the plant and your success.

Tomato Question 3

I’ve heard that chopping off the tops of indeterminate tomatoes toward the end of the season will help ripen the fruit that’s left on the vine. Is that true? —Debbie Burke, Willmar, Minnesota

SD: If the plant is stopped from creating further top growth and creating additional flowers, then it can concentrate on the task at hand: ripening the fruit. So yes, this approach works and is a great tactic to take. You might want to try the following steps as well, to ripen the fruit quicker:

  • Don’t coddle the plant. Cut back on irrigation (or turn it off altogether), and stop fertilizing. A little stress will send a signal that the plant has to make seed (fruit) and that should speed up ripening, too.
  • Remove any dead leaves along with top growth and flowers. This can help arrest any disease advance that might attack late in the season.
  • Pick fruit as soon as the color break is apparent. The term “color break” refers to when the shoulders of the tomato start to turn (photo). Picking the fruit at this time helps decrease the fruit load on the plant, which, in turn, reduces the amount of energy the plant is using. Ripen the underripe fruit in a cool, dark pantry or similar spot.

Tomato Question 4

Blight seems to attack my plants every year. Is there anything I can do—or not do—to stop this from ruining my crop? —Darma Engel, Morrisville, Vermont

SD: The first step is figuring out which blight you have. Early blight often appears at the start of the season and makes the plant look bad but allows some fruiting. Late blight ruins the plant, the fruit, and your season. I suspect that you’ve battled late blight because your crop has been ruined repeatedly.

Use these steps to avoid the problem in the future:

Grow tomatoes somewhere else. This will avoid any residual bits of the disease being an issue.

Clean up thoroughly—and immediately—when your season ends. Remove all debris and any volunteer seedlings from the garden. Don’t add it to your compost pile. If you’ve grown potatoes in or near this space, get rid of them, as well, as disease might overwinter in forgotten tubers or roots.

Amend heavily, and add a good organic fertilizer. Continue to enrich the soil in this spot with compost all year long. Poor soil heightens blight conditions.

Space your seedlings. Place the plants as far apart as possible to allow for more air circulation between plants and less opportunity for the spread of disease. Six feet or more apart would be sufficient.

Use a rigid grid to support your plants (photo). This allows you to spread the leaves out, rather than bunch them tightly in a cage or similar support, and that will lead to better airflow.

Irrigate on the ground. This limits moisture and soil splashing (and, thus, spreading disease) on the leaves and stems.

Screen/shield the garden to limit windy conditions. Fungal spores tend to spread via gusty winds.

Use organic fungicides in rotation and on a regular schedule. And be attentive: It’s easier to control blight if you catch it in its early stages.

Tomato Question 5

If I practice crop rotation, I know that I shouldn’t plant tomatoes in the same spot the following year. But how far away can I plant them? A few feet away? A few inches? I’m not sure what qualifies as a “different location”? —Brian Moore, Bowie, Maryland 

SD: Crop rotation is your single best deterrent to disease or pest problems in the tomato garden. Bottom line: Change the location of the tomato garden as much as you can. With lots of property, that’s easy, right? One year, you plant the front 40, and then the next year the back 40. But it’s not so easy in a smaller garden where we have to basically use the same space each year. If you’re planting in raised garden beds or using multiple garden areas, then move plants each year from one section or bed to another. Moving from one side of a small garden bed to the other might help, but, really, whom are we kidding? You’re still in the same spot. Move those plants as much as you can and then employ these other healthy ideas:

Grow disease-resistant varieties. If you have disease problems that persist from year to year, choose tomato varieties that show some resistance to common tomato problems.

Keep a clean and tidy garden. This is important during the season as well as after. When the season is over, clean up like a maniac to get any diseased leaves and debris out of the garden. Avoid the compost pile with this lot.

Add compost. To keep the soil active, work in some compost. This will raise an army of beneficial organisms that will battle against disease organisms, fungal spores, and more.

Leave the soil alone. If the disease is persistent, leave the soil fallow for as long as you can. Mulch heavily with compost and leaves, then grow in containers right on top of the bed. Or better yet, grow in containers in another part of the garden and plant other, less disease-prone veggies in the original bed.

Previous: 6 Ways to Protect Your Tomatoes From Birds Next: 8 Tomato Myths Debunked
View Comments


  1. uttaraghodke 06/23/2015

    Just came across this wonderful link. Going to try growing tomatoes at home now.Nice

Log in or create an account to post a comment.

Fruits and Vegetables

Fruits and Vegetables

Growing your own food is easy with the help of this comprehensive step-by-step guide

View Project Guide

View All Project Guides »

Become a member and get unlimited site access, including the Fruits and Vegetables Project Guide.

Start Free Trial

Cool-Season Crops
Warm-Season Crops