Chop potatoes into bite-sized pieces. I like red-skinned and leave some skin, trimming off bad spots or eyes if need be. Put them in a pot and barely cover with water; cook until just tender--not too soft. Click on other pix to enlarge and read captions.Photo/Illustration: susan belsinger
For about 3 to 5 pounds of potatoes, I use a small onion, chopped; 2 chopped hardboiled eggs; and 1 or 2 stalks of chopped celery. Combine them in a bowl, season with sea salt and freshly ground pepper and toss.Photo/Illustration: susan belsinger
Either use a bottled Italian dressing or mix up your own using olive oil, vinegar, couple cloves pressed garlic, minced herbs, and season well with sea salt and freshly ground pepper.Photo/Illustration: susan belsinger
Transfer the cooked potatoes to drain in a colander and pour the dressing over the hot potatoes (I use about 1/2 to 3/4 cup dressing for 3 pounds potatoes and 1 cup for 5 pounds). They absorb the dressing immediately.Photo/Illustration: susan belsinger
Once the potatoes have cooled to warm, add them to the bowl with onions, celery and egg and toss. Use about 1 generous cup of good-quality mayonnaise (you might need more). I use a few teaspoons of maple mustard, although my sister doesn't add mustard. (She adds a teaspoon or two of sugar). Sometimes, I add a few tablespoons of sweet pickle juice. Combine well and taste; adjust with mayo, vinegar, sugar, salt and pepper. Refrigerate until ready to serve.Photo/Illustration: susan belsinger
Most folks celebrate Independence Day with a cookout or picnic. When I think of quintessential summer foods to accompany this event–potato salad and coleslaw, summer ripe tomatoes and corn-on-the-cob immediately come to mind–they are American as apple pie. Here’s a loose recipe for my sister, Doneth’s potato salad, which is truly a family favorite.
Our family get-togethers can be a bit demanding because we have family favorites that always need to be included. From Donny’s potato salad and Lucie’s deviled eggs to mom’s spinach balls and Aunt Janet’s baked horseradish carrots, these are recipes that we want again and again and never get bored. My Mema Ella always made her famous butter cookies that she pressed out with her cookie gun and her yellow pound cake with chocolate frosting and we had them at every family gathering. Although I watched Mema make these many times and wrote the recipe exactly the way she made it, they don’t taste exactly the way she made them.
Each person puts their own spin on things. Donny’s secret to a very tasty potato salad is that she uses a bottled Italian dressing that she pours over the hot potatoes once she drains them in the colander–they sog the dressing up readily–which gives them added flavor. I usually make my own vinaigrettes, so I mix up olive oil, vinegar (apple cider, white wine or rice wine), a few fresh (or dried) minced herbs, a clove or two of pressed garlic and generous amounts of sea salt and freshly ground pepper.
The family isn’t all together on this Fourth of July, however according to the family texts flying about, three of us made my sister’s potato salad. Hers always tastes the best, although the rest of us make a pretty close rendition. (I’m sure that she is rolling her eyes at me at the mention of pickle juice… ).
Hope that wherever you are and whomever you are with–you have a happy, safe and delicious Fourth of July celebration!
Get our latest tips, how-to articles, and instructional videos sent to your inbox.