Thoughts from a Foreign Field

Vegetable vs Flower Gardening – Why not both?

vegetables in a bin

I have been thinking about the pros and cons of vegetable gardening versus flower gardening.purple flowers bloomingSome people are of the opinion that flowers are a waste of good productive space. That they are a frippery that should be sacrificed in order that we can grow more food. An interesting discussion about which I have strong views…We have a saying over here: “All work and no play, makes Jack a dull boy” (which, incidentally is an Egyptian proverb first recorded in 2400BC) which is a pretty sensible maxim for not only life but gardens. In the latter case in can perhaps be adapted to “All veg and no flowers, sucks some of the poetry from Jack’s soul”. A tad clumsy but you know what I mean.Do gardens always have to be useful? It sometimes seems that to just enjoy your garden is not enough and you must also use it as a way to counteract the sins of the modern world. Carrots are not just grown for the pleasure of their earthy taste but to combat the evils of supermarkets. Men in sheds cannot grow competitive celeriac or seek after the perfect pair of plums without thinking first of carbon neutrality. I worry that there is danger that gardening may no longer be something that people do just for amusement but instead it has to be for much worthier reasons like reducing food miles or escaping from the noxious scatterings of assorted agri-chemicals.

beautiful red and yellow and green foliage spread out through trees
Believe me; I am thoroughly in favour of growing our own food. I fully appreciate that there are few things more satisfying than to grow, pick and eat your own produce but nobody should be under any illusion that it is either particularly easy or terribly cheap. You need to expend a great deal of effort and a lot of time before you get even the simplest ratatouille. But it is also important to leave space to just enjoy the garden for no other reason apart from a straightforward appreciation of its beauty.I have to admit that virtually nothing that I grow in my garden is edible by anything other than the crowds of pillaging gastropods that, during the hours of darkness, descend upon the plants like an Assyrian horde. You could probably chew a rose petal or snack upon the odd Nasturtium but there is nothing here that will make you even slightly plump. There is a vegetable patch but that is the fiefdom of my wife, I concentrate purely on the decorative and mildly decadent. There is still hard work involved but the end result is designed merely to be gorgeous and give succour to the senses.It is sadly true that you cannot live off the scent of roses or reduce the National Debt by lyingon the grass staring into the canopies of trees. The plight of the starving cannot be eased by the flowering of even a trillion tulips nor can politicians be swayed by the ululations of ornamental grasses.  All the same we should take time luxuriate in the  glory of colour, shape and frivolous exuberance that make up our gardens. To walk down paths overspilt with billowing Geraniums, to sit under the shade of flowering cherries and to fritter away a warm afternoon upended and busy in a flower border. It is in experiences like this that pure, unalloyed and transient pleasure can be found. To extreme puritans it may seem wasteful and unacceptable to waste good growing ground on such things but the nourishment to be gained from a perfect poppy or an iridescent Iris should never be underestimated.

trees and bushes surrounding a gravel path purple and yellow flowers

Of course the best thing is a happy compromise. To combine the healthy exercise and dietary satisfaction of growing your own vegetables with the pure pleasure of wallowing among flowers. That way Jack remains well fed in both mind and body.

vegetables ready to eat spread out on a table


View Comments


  1. user-7008077 05/20/2016

    While I'm strictly a vegetable grower, I can understand both sides. If someone wants to grow both or even just flowers, that's their perogative.

    Please feel free to check out and comment on my blog : https:// I'm fairly new to the game so I'm open to any ideas or suggestions. Thank you!

    1. grannieannie1 07/12/2016

      Flowers can always be squeezed into vegetable gardens somewhere. At least that is my experience. Peach and dark red GLADIOLI don't mind being squashed between a row of pavers and my raised tomato and strawberry bed. They come up every year along with a tall fire engine red CARDINAL FLOWER that seeded itself. One CYPRESS VINE I planted from seed is growing with pole beans on a trellis. A mat of white SWEET ALYSSUM shows up yearly with tomatoes as does a bright salmon BALSAM and one in purple. A yellow, multi flowered SUNFLOWER seeded itself just inside the gate. Dark purple MORNING GLORIES ride the fence that keeps out the critters. And then there are pots of flowers placed along the paths...the more the happier I am when going out to pick vegetables.

  2. diane_lasauce 05/20/2016

    Last fall I converted all five raised beds to bulbs. After fifteen years, I gave up on outsmarting the chewing insects on anything edible. This way I have beauty galore and when I want veggies, I support the local organic farmers at the farmer's market.
    Life must be filled with as much eye candy as possible.

  3. antigonum_cajan 05/20/2016

    I find boring, dull, spaces planted only with vegetables. Most of the time they exist with the only purpose of eating, not thought in terms of biodiversity in a biocentric perspective focus, considering the flora/fauna in context, particularly the urban concrete/asphalt where most people in the world reside. On the other hand, even more dull, is the lack of wide focus when discussing the subject...The concept is not flowers/veggies, but GARDENS and pollinators...the urge of planning for both...It is hilarious to find people with no idea of the importance of pollinators to obtain edibles...never passing through their minds vegetation/flowers to attract them permanently.

Log in or create an account to post a comment.

Related Articles

The Latest