From the pages of Fine Gardening Magazine

What's the Best-Tasting Heirloom Tomato?

The results of the 2002 Tomatomania taste-testing are in! See which tomato is tops.

In the regional pages of the July/August 2002 issue of Fine Cooking, we featured Tomatomania, a Los Angeles event celebrating heirloom tomatoes. Seedlings of 175 varieties were sold, in anticipation of a harvest-time tasting extravaganza that took place in August. The results are in!

A basketful of heirloom tomatoes Tasters at work
Taste-testing tomatoes was an easy job for this group of heirloom-tomato enthusiasts.

The number one best-tasting heirloom tomato at this year's tasting was 'Black Plum', followed closely by another black variety, 'Carbon', and 'Sweet Olive', a cherry tomato variety. Popular old-timer cherry 'Sungold' followed in fourth place.

Here's the complete top 10!
  1. 'Black Plum'
  2. 'Carbon'
  3. 'Sweet Olive'
  4. 'Sungold'
  5. 'Goliath'
  6. 'Green Zebra'
  7. 'Odoriko'
  8. 'Paul Robeson'
  9. 'Goose Creek'
  10. 'Black Zebra

Photos: Courtesy of Sam Hamann

From Fine Gardening #88
Purchase back issues


The Art of the Kitchen Garden
Learn how to mingle flowers and vegetables to create gardens bountiful in color and produce

The Gardener's Guide to Common-Sense Pest Control
Discover hundreds of environmentally effective ways to control garden pests

Kitchen Gardener Back Issues
Order now for the best selection