• Plant Finder: Spring Plants
    Plant Finder: Spring Plants
  • Seed Starting in Speedling Trays
    Seed Starting in Speedling Trays
  • Using Containers as Elements of a Design
    Using Containers as Elements of a Design
  • 3 Ways to Design with Containers
    3 Ways to Design with Containers
  • Garden Design Basics
    Garden Design Basics
  • Building Better Borders
    Building Better Borders
  • Planting the Right Way
    Planting the Right Way
  • Get your FREE Everyday Roses download now!
    Get your FREE Everyday Roses download now!
  • Homegrown / Homemade
    Homegrown / Homemade
  • How to Grow Mustard
    How to Grow Mustard
  • DIY A-Frame Veggie Trellis
    DIY A-Frame Veggie Trellis
  • Bold and Beautiful Zinnias
    Bold and Beautiful Zinnias
  • 10 Combinations for Shade
    10 Combinations for Shade
  • Pick Plants for Fragrance
    Pick Plants for Fragrance
  • Go Green on the Patio
    Go Green on the Patio
  • Black Plants Done Right
    Black Plants Done Right
  • 10 Seed-Starting Tips
    10 Seed-Starting Tips
  • Pantone Color of the Year 2014: Radiant Orchid
    Pantone Color of the Year 2014: Radiant Orchid
  • NEW Video Series: There's a Better Way
    NEW Video Series: There's a Better Way
  • 20 Gardenworthy Self-Sowers
    20 Gardenworthy Self-Sowers
  • Indoor Seed Starting Materials List
    Indoor Seed Starting Materials List
  • Rex Begonias
    Rex Begonias

Roses And That Cup Of Bone Meal In The Planting Hole

comments (3) July 14th, 2011 in blogs
PFZimmerman Paul Zimmerman, contributor
44 users recommend

The roses at my old nursery.  Not planted with bone meal. Click the image to enlarge.

The roses at my old nursery.  Not planted with bone meal.

Photo: Paul Zimmerman Roses

When planting roses one of the most common instructions is always to “toss a cup of bone meal in the bottom of the hole”.  The reasoning behind this is that bone meal is phosphate, roses really need it and since it doesn’t travel through the soil quickly it’s best to put it in the hole.

I used to do this very early in my rose days, but then stopped doing so when I started the nursery.  I did a soil analysis and the results didn’t call for it.  I’ve not done it since and quite frankly never noticed any difference.  So I never thought about it again, and when people asked me if they should use it I simply replied by saying you can if you want to but I don’t.

I figured after all, what harm can it do?

At least that is what I thought until someone posted a link on our Discussion Forum to a short paper by Linda Chalker-Scott, Ph.D., Extension Horticulturist and Associate Professor, Puyallup Research and Extension Center, Washington State University.  She entitled the paper

“The Myth of Phosphate, Part II.  Roses need phosphate fertilizer for root and flower growth”

She began by noting that she could not find any scientific research saying that roses needed more phosphate than other plants.  And in fact the phosphate levels of most soils are perfectly adequate for roses and all plants – something my soil analysis and observations noted all those years ago.

But then the next part really made me stand up and take notice.  I quote.

“Numerous studies have demonstrated that roses, like most terrestrial plants, maintain symbiotic relationships with beneficial fungi. If you add phosphate to your rose plants, you will decrease the ability of mycorrhizal fungi to colonize the rose roots.”

That was an eye opener.  I’ve always preached against those systemic all in one fertilizers, fungicides and insecticides because studies show the have an impact on vital soil life but this was new.  Professor Chalker goes on to add.

“Without these fungal partners, rose roots must work harder to extract water and nutrients from the soil. Moreover, this excess phosphate is injurious to other soil organisms. With increased fertilizer additions, soil salinity increases. You have now created an artificial system in which soil health is so impacted that you must continue to add fertilizer for your plants to survive.”

Now that last statement is great news if you own stock in a chemical fertilizer company but not good news for your roses.  Those living soil organisms supply the natural nutrients that work in harmony with your roses to boost their own natural immune system.  Professor Chalker is suggesting that by adding artificial fertilizers we are actually getting in the way of that process.

Professor Chalker-Scott goes on to say this.

“I believe this is what has happened in many landscapes that feature roses. Well-intentioned, yet misguided, homeowners over apply phosphate and other fertilizers, insecticides, and fungicides until the soil system is so impacted that it becomes non-functional. Without the beneficial soil organisms, roses become more susceptible to nutrient deficiencies and opportunistic diseases, causing rose aficionados to add even more of these chemicals.”

One more reason to just treat roses like any other plant.  After all Roses Are Plants, Too.

Happy Roseing

If you wish to read the paper click here for a link.

posted in: planting, fertilizing

Comments (3)

wwross writes:
Thanks Susan 749. So what is the concensus on bone meal and bulbs? Are we wasting our money and time using it? I had always assumed that some type of fertilizer is needed for them to keep blooming year after year.
Posted: 9:09 am on July 18th
PFZimmerman writes: I've heard that from others. Now you have another reason! Posted: 9:41 am on July 16th
susan749 writes: Another reason I found not to use bone meal is that my dogs love it. I planted some bulbs following that advice about bone meal for bulbs (which you have now made me question) and the next day every hole was dug up by the dogs. Same thing happened with the 1" diameter pellet of ? sent to me by a plant nursery with a shrub order. I assume the pellet must have contained bone meal and perhaps fish meal; at any rate, the dogs loved it. No more bone meal for me! Posted: 9:57 pm on July 15th
You must be logged in to post comments. Log in.